izhilzha (izhilzha) wrote,
izhilzha
izhilzha

  • Mood:

Some notes on Doctor Who, CSI, and Scrubs

Hopefully, the first two of these will be short. :-) Because it's Doctor Who I actually have opinions about.


I'm really very fond of this show. It's strange, and I don't exactly fangirl it when I'm not watching, but there's a living heart to each character that the humor only accentuates. No one, even when they're exaggerated, seems unreal.

And preaching? What's that? Even when the topic is abortion.... *blows kisses to the writers, actors, and everybody*



CSI, "Loco Motives"

I've heard several people, both online and RL, complaining about this episode. Either it was an unsatisfactory conclusion to the minature-models murderer storyline (more on that in a second), or it was just "confusing."

I will grant some on the second one. CSI, on the whole, is very good about revealing both the 'how' (which is what they're famous for) and the 'why,' or motives, behind each crime they solve. Even (or maybe especially) when the killer is one that has eluded them before, like Paul Millander (whose background was bizarre, and who had an eeire raport with Grissom); or like the Blue Paint Killer, who was a straight-up psycho-sexual serial killer.

And it's true that we don't get a complete and total explanation of Dell's motives. It almost seems very simple and sordid; an elaborate ritual to get back at people who have somehow harmed him. Maybe.

But there, I think, is the center of this episode. People don't seem to be getting that this one isn't about solving the case--or rather, yes, it is about that, but it's also about the fact that even when they solve one, sometimes it doesn't work out. Grissom will never understand Dell more than he does right now, from his studies of the models and that last web video. He caught him, but it wasn't a duel between nemeses...just a game of cat and mouse between men who are perhaps a little too much alike.

Catherine astutely observes that Grissom seems "tired." She wouldn't even ask if she didn't mean something beyond normal fatigue, and I think she's right. Grissom is close to burnout, for whatever reason.

Also, I actually found the subplot--the man who has accidentally killed four people--to be much more disturbing. I understand why Cath couldn't stop laughing, but I also understand what horrified Grissom about that; it's something completely out of the man's control, and he's going to have to pay for it above and beyond the deaths. That's wrenching, and if I think about it too hard, makes me feel a bit sick.

So I actually thought this episode was pretty good. And I'm glad Dell wasn't just a carbon copy of Millander.



Doctor Who, "Love and Monsters"

*blink, blink* Okay then. Did we just fall off the edge of the universe into Sunnydale for about an hour, here?

I actually liked a lot about this episode (I am sometimes a complete sucker for alternate-POV episodes of my favorite shows, so...). Here's a list:

--The main character, believe it or not. I liked Elton a lot, and I especially liked that he actually got a realistic character arc.
--Jackie Tyler! She annoyed me beyond words a while back, but I've grown to love her, and it was so nice to see things from her side for a change.
--The short, small, character sketches of the rest of the group (LINDA? Yes?); elegant, spare, and including Shirley...oh, shoot, I do know her name. Moaning Myrtle, you know. Always fun to have her in a role.
--Good use of music, imho. :-)
--Very interesting extrapolation of how people might talk about the Doctor, if they don't know much about him, really. Religious ideas, philosophical ideas, how-this-applies-to-us (WWTDT?).

Things I didn't:

--I've been noting a few Buffy references this season, most of which got an amused "hey look!" from me, followed by an explanation to my non-Buffy roomie. This, though...so much of this episode had me flashing back to "Storyteller," which though clever, wasn't one of my favorite season 7 episodes. In fact, the parallels with the storytelling exaggerations (at the beginning, at least), the video cuts, even the look of the actor who played Elton (short blonde hair, thin, narrow face, sorta geeky) reminded me of Andrew Wells and his supposed documentation of Buffy and her house of Slayers-in-training.
--If that was on purpose, it's a problem. I'm not willing to take anything Elton says at face value till I don't know, almost half-way through the episode? I expected much more of a screen between us and reality, since he's telling the story and could tell it however the heck he wants to. This narrator is much more honest than Andrew, but how was I to know that right off?
--The bit at the end, the weird sort of half-happy-ending that the Doctor manages with his sonic screwdriver of all things...what *can't* that thing do? Stretch my disbelief, I guess.
--Also, seeing the events of the past couple of years from someone's earthbound perspective really made the fact that both Nine and Ten didn't seem to do much in the way of backtracking anywhere close to their path in the "current" timeline stand out sharply. Poo. If you have time travelling, why not mix it up a little? It's fun that way! If the Doctor has worked with previous incarnations before.... *sigh*


I think that's all for now. Though I may have a bit of a rant about SG-1 and God vs. false gods at some point ("Origin" frustrated me quite a lot).
Tags: csi, doctor who, scrubs, stargate sg-1
Subscribe

  • Fan fic recollections -- AKA oh dear, AO3 formatting...

    So I'm finally getting around to fixing formatting on some of my fics which I transferred over to Archive of Our Own a couple of years ago. I went…

  • SG-1 Fic: Q is for Quitting

    Q is for Quitting, by izhilzha (PG) Summary: Letters written and never sent, from one team member to the others. Word count: 1,352 words…

  • I've been podficced! :)

    You guys! I am so excited right now, and happy, and feeling super fannish! :) A lovely gal named litra, over on AO3, asked a few weeks ago if she…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 5 comments